Excerpts from "The other side of ideology"
By Tali Tamir, Curator
Haim Maor's (of Kibbutz Givat Haim Meuchad) work - "Raik vs Reich" is situated
in the third floor of the Yad Ya'ari archives, the institute of research
and documentation of Hashomer Hatza'ir movement. Maor's installation is set
up in the center of an active archive, amongst rows of shelves laden with
numbered cardboard boxes, containing impressive chapters of the history of
the movement. The penetration into the spaces of memory (while monitoring
admission times and people admitted to preserve the archives) amounts to
penetrating history itself. The installation focuses on a historic figure
connected to a World War II Jewish valiance myth: The parachutist Haviva
Raik, who gave her name to Givat Haviva. Raik was one of three women in a
team of thirty-seven parachutists who were sent to occupied Europe by the
Zionist authorities in Palestine .Their mission was to rescue Jews. Raik
and several others were killed on that mission. but only one of the members
- the poet Hana Senesh - has become a national legend of valor and dedication.
The others remained anonymous. Maor's installation "Raik vs. Reich" deals
with the manner In which history sorts out its data, the details that escape.
and the mechanisms supporting and reconstructing the collective memory.
Maor probes the dead memories which gather dust on the archive shelves. He
converts the archive master's desk, for one month, to Haviva Raik's personal
desk. A desk loaded with photographs. memorial paraphernalia, and thirty-seven
folded parachutes bestowing symbolic life on thirty seven forgotten paratroopers.
Although Maor's installation occupies itself with an event from World War
LI, its essence - the struggle between History and Mythology - bonds it to
the general subject of the exhibition: The position or predisposition of
the individual with respect to the heavy burden of ideology. The myth - this
time - not a didactic. illuminating message. but rather an entity capable
of floodlighting the environment, causing partial blindness and lethal
forgetfulness. The proficiency at telling Raik's story from a different angle
attests to the possibility that History in its entirety can be deciphered
differently, relieved of dogma and reconstructed anew. The space hosting
the work, the archive, is a passive one. waiting in readiness for the historians
undertaking. However. "We. who are prepared to remember at any cost", writes
Maor. " lubricate our memorial devices in the open archive. I remember, therefore
I exist".
Haim maor: "Raik vs. Reich"
An installation in the Givat Haviva archives
as part of "Art Focus"
October 1994
"Honoring the memory of the unknown is a dignified task, tougher than
commemorating the renowned. The building of History is dedicated to the memory
of the unknown!"
Walter Benjamin
"Who is to decide what is to become historically meaningful and what shall
forever perish from the collective memory of Mankind?
There are no errors in History. History itself is an error."
Bracho Dmitriewitch
"Even the remembering generation goes on dying, some happily, some not, and
who shall remember those who remember?"
Yehudah Amichai
Remembering is potency
Forgetting is comfortable
Spirits of the memories
I do not create memory generating objects; on the contrary
The memories themselves generate and create objects.
In other words, if we picture memories as living creatures, I spy after the
dead memories.
I raise them from the dead, clutch the strings of past memories, clothing
them with a temporary visual vision in the Present.
Memories of the past are but a looking glass, a mirror with which we reflect
clearly and accurately the occurrences of the present. It is another device
in the struggle of History with Mythology.
One and all
It all begins with an actual event. It happens to ordinary people during
the normal course of their lives in a given time and place. From here on
Mythology begins to gnaw at History: We isolate a single person or a single
group, transforming that person or that group into a symbol of the event.
The event reformulates, turning into a 'story'. The details present themselves
at the service of the collective memory and the national or international
consciousness. Thus, out of the desire to remember, some of the figures involved
are forgotten. The original event 'surrenders' and becomes a 'legend' or
a 'myth'.
This technique is easy for the utilization of the human perception mechanisms
and the power institutions of government.
The archives and the hidden facts
The archives store and preserve documents, photos, artifacts and facts of
life. There, inside the cases stored on the shelves of these archives, they
become the substance of History.
The sealed cases store facts which are hidden from sight and consciousness.
Stored inside the archives of Givat Haviva is the historic legacy of "Hashbmer
Hatsa-eer" movement and Hakibbutz Ha'artsi. This legacy makes for a substantial
chapter in the history of the Jewish people in Europe and in Israel.
The tales of the ordeal of thirty seven 12parachutists, three of whom women,
are revealed through these archives. Sent from Palestine to occupied Europe
during World War II, they were instructed to do their outmost to save Jews
from the Nazis. Some were killed on that mission, some passed away, others
died in an accident that took place during the ten year memorial ceremony
to Peretz Goldstein, one of their comrades, when a light airplane crashed
into the assembled crowd at Kibbutz Ma'agan in 1954. The rest are still living
in Israel.
In years to come this ordeal has turned into yet another glorious chapter
in the Jewish-Israeli experience. One of the women involved, the poetess
and parachutist Hana Senesh, has become a martyr and a symbol in her own
right.
Haviva Raik, who gave her name to the Givat Haviva Seminary, was killed on
that mission. She and her comrades, heretofore obscure in the Historic-collective
lore, return to the archival shelves, alive inside folded parachutes carrying
their personal ID tags..
The desk of the archive master becomes - for one month - that of Haviva Raik's,
a personal desk, full of photographs and memories.
Spiritless parachutists
The installation "Raik versus Reich" grants symbolic life to thirty-seven
spiritless parachutists. Parachutes are scattered on the operation table
as umbrellas, next to the sewing machines. The parachutists weep at night,
and the good ones demand the alleviation of their indignity.
We, who are prepared to remember at whatever cost, lubricate our memorial
mechanisms within the open archives. I remember, therefore I exist.
|